TY - JOUR T1 - Identification of effectiveness assessment criteria for Seminary virtual courses TT - تعیین ملاک ‏های سنجش اثربخشی دوره ‏های آموزش مجازی حوزوی JF - cstp JO - cstp VL - 1 IS - 1 UR - http://cstp.khu.ac.ir/article-1-1851-en.html Y1 - 2014 SP - 73 EP - 100 KW - Grounded theory KW - Seminary education KW - virtual instruction KW - and effectiveness N2 - The main purpose of this research is to derive Seminary virtual education effectiveness criteria. Seminary education has main differences with tertiary or professional education. Therefore, to assess their effectiveness, we must take into account these differences. In this research we have used qualitative methodology and set a semi-interview mechanism with 15 experts in e-learning, all employees in Seminary educational institutions established in Qom. Data analysis was done in three stages: open encoding, axial encoding and selective encoding. In open encoding stage 114 codes was detected. In axial encoding stage these codes were categorized around six basic categories. With recurrent reviewing of interviews in selective coding stage we reached one inclusive category. Based on these research findings, to assess Seminary virtual education’s effectiveness, there are two layers, i.e. surface and deep. In surface layer we must consider six categories which include: Seminary’s essential values, seminary educational aims, curriculum design, teacher skills, learner skills and behavioral and attitudinal outcomes. But in deep layer, based on Seminary essential values and interactions among six categories, it boiled down to one inclusive category which we called “Seminarian traits”. This concept involves elements such as: Seminarian style, religious inquiry, propagation skills, observing the teacher’s dignity, developing an inner feeling and life-long learning. M3 ER -